THE EYECLINIC BY DR CHERYL LEE
ICL vs LASIK vs Smile in Singapore
Which Is right for You?
Evo ICL · LASIK · Dry eyes
How to Get Rid of Glasses in Singapore
LASIK vs Smile vs ICL
Which Vision Correction Surgery Is Better?
LASIK and Smile reshape the cornea with a laser. ICL adds a lens inside the eye, without removing corneal tissue, and it can be removed or replaced later. Both are primary options in their own right. Which fits you depends on your eyes, and on what matters to you — for example, whether you want to keep your cornea untouched and keep the option to reverse it.
This page compares the two fairly, explains what happens at a suitability assessment, and helps you decide which fits you. It is general information only, not a diagnosis or a recommendation for you personally. Only an assessment can tell which option is safest for you.
ICL vs LASIK vs Smile
Many patients considering vision correction ask me whether LASIK or Smile or EVO Implantable Collamer® Lens (ICL) surgery is the better option.
Both procedures can reduce dependence on glasses and contact lenses, but they work in very different ways and may suit different types of eyes.
At The EyeClinic by Dr Cheryl Lee, I assess every patient personally to determine the most suitable vision correction procedure for them.
WHAT IS LASIK?
LASIK (Laser-Assisted In Situ Keratomileusis) is a laser procedure that reshapes the cornea to correct refractive errors such as myopia, astigmatism and hyperopia.
During LASIK:
a thin flap is created in the cornea
a laser reshapes the cornea
the flap is repositioned
The new shape allows light to focus more accurately on the retina. LASIK can provide excellent vision for many patients with mild-to-moderate myopia or astigmatism.
LASIK is long-established and widely performed, and it does not involve surgery inside the eye.
However, because LASIK removes corneal tissue, the changes are permanent and cannot be reversed.
What Is SMILE?
SMILE stands for Small Incision Lenticule Extraction. It is a laser procedure that corrects myopia and astigmatism, usually mild-to-moderate.
During SMILE, a femtosecond laser creates a small, lens-shaped piece of tissue (a lenticule) inside the cornea, and that piece is removed through a tiny incision, a few millimetres wide. No flap is made in the cornea. Removing the lenticule changes the shape of the cornea, so light focuses more accurately on the retina.
Because there is no flap, and fewer corneal nerves are cut than with LASIK, dry eye after SMILE is less likely than after LASIK. However, like LASIK, SMILE removes corneal tissue, so the change is permanent and cannot be reversed.
WHAT IS AN EVO IMPLANTABLE CONTACT LENS (ICL)?
The Swiss EVO Implantable Contact Lens (ICL) is a small, biocompatible lens placed inside the eye, behind the iris and in front of the natural lens.
Instead of reshaping the cornea, the lens works with your natural eye to focus light correctly. One difference is that ICL does not remove corneal tissue.
The lens can also be removed or replaced if needed, making the procedure reversible. That can matter later in life, when vision changes occur — for example, when cataracts or presbyopia develop.
WHICH ONE IS BETTER FOR YOU?
Neither is better in general. Neither is a fallback for the other.
LASIK may suit you if…
You are happy with a permanent change to the cornea, you prefer laser on the surface of the eye rather than surgery inside the eye, and your prescription, corneal thickness and eye health suit laser.
ICL may suit you if…
You do not want corneal tissue removed, and you want the option to reverse it later when you develop reading vision problems which will happen as we all get older
You are concerned about dry eyes
Some patients experience dry eye symptoms after laser vision correction because corneal nerves are affected during the procedure.
As EVO ICL does not reshape the cornea in the same way, it may be an important option for patients concerned about dry eyes.
WHAT ABOUT OTHER OPTIONS?
Refractive lens exchange — replacing the natural lens, for presbyopia or early cataract, in suitable patients.
Ortho-Keratology — also called Dream Lens, overnight contact lenses.
WHAT HAPPENS AT A SUITABILITY ASSESSMENT?
Vision and prescription check
Anterior chamber depth — the key check for whether you are an ICL candidate
Corneal thickness and shape (topography) — the key check for LASIK
Eye pressure and eye health check
Dry eye assessment
Discussion of ICL vs LASIK vs other options, and what is safest for you
A detailed eye examination is necessary to determine which option is safest. Bring your glasses and, if you wear them, your contact lenses and their prescription.
FAQ
Is ICL safer than LASIK?
Both procedures are considered safe when performed on suitable patients. The best option depends on individual eye anatomy and visual needs.
I take additional steps to reduce ICL risks, such as UBM ultrasound for ICL sizing. Read about it here.
Can ICL cause dry eyes?
EVO ICL does not reshape the cornea, so it does not affect the corneal nerves in the way laser can. Dry eye can still occur for other reasons, and your dry eye status is part of the assessment.
Is ICL reversible?
Yes. One of the advantages of EVO ICL is that the lens can be removed or exchanged in the future, for example when cataract or presbyopia deve
WHICH ONE IS BETTER FOR YOU?
Neither is better in general. Neither is a fallback for the other.
LASIK may suit you if…
You are happy with a permanent change to the cornea, you prefer laser on the surface of the eye rather than surgery inside the eye, and your prescription, corneal thickness and eye health suit laser.
ICL may suit you if…
You do not want corneal tissue removed, and you want the option to reverse it later when you develop reading vision problems which will happen as we all get older
You are concerned about dry eyes
Some patients experience dry eye symptoms after laser vision correction because corneal nerves are affected during the procedure.
As EVO ICL does not reshape the cornea in the same way, it may be an important option for patients concerned about dry eyes.
WHAT ABOUT OTHER OPTIONS?
Refractive lens exchange — replacing the natural lens, for presbyopia or early cataract, in suitable patients.
Ortho-Keratology — also called Dream Lens, overnight contact lenses.
WHAT HAPPENS AT A SUITABILITY ASSESSMENT?
Vision and prescription check
Anterior chamber depth — the key check for whether you are an ICL candidate
Corneal thickness and shape (topography) — the key check for LASIK
Eye pressure and eye health check
Dry eye assessment
Discussion of ICL vs LASIK vs other options, and what is safest for you
A detailed eye examination is necessary to determine which option is safest. Bring your glasses and, if you wear them, your contact lenses and their prescription.
FAQ
Is ICL safer than LASIK?
Both procedures are considered safe when performed on suitable patients. The best option depends on individual eye anatomy and visual needs.
I take additional steps to reduce ICL risks, such as UBM ultrasound for ICL sizing. Read about it here.
Can ICL cause dry eyes?
EVO ICL does not reshape the cornea, so it does not affect the corneal nerves in the way laser can. Dry eye can still occur for other reasons, and your dry eye status is part of the assessment.
Is ICL reversible?
Yes. One of the advantages of EVO ICL is that the lens can be removed or exchanged in the future, for example when cataract or presbyopia develops.
Implantable Contact Lens verus PRK vs Lasik
An ICL story I have never forgotten
Many years ago, I met a German lady who had received one of the earliest implantable contact lenses approximately 25 years earlier.
By the time she came to see me, her eyes — and her visual needs — had naturally changed. She had developed presbyopia and wanted to explore a different solution for her vision.
This meant removing the ICL that had been sitting quietly inside her eye for around a quarter of a century.
I remember the moment very clearly.
The lens slipped out smoothly.
After approximately 25 years inside the eye, I was struck by how straightforward it was to remove and by the absence of the sort of scarring one might imagine after something had remained inside the eye for so long.
As surgeons, we often use the word “reversible” when we talk about ICL.
But that experience made the word very real for me.
I had removed an ICL after approximately 25 years. The lens could come out. The cornea had never been reshaped.
That patient reinforced something that has become central to the way I think about refractive surgery.
Your eyes will change throughout your lifetime. The treatment we choose today should, wherever possible, respect the eye you may have many years from now.
That is one of the reasons I value ICL: not simply for the vision it can provide today, but for the anatomy it allows us to preserve for tomorrow.
— Dr Cheryl Lee